⚖ Vote Tracker

← Federal courts · Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas

A federal trial (district) court in the Fifth Circuit. 10 active judges and 7 on senior status (semi-retired, still hearing some cases), per the Federal Judicial Center.

No left–right score is calculated for lower-court judges. The appointing president is shown instead (a common, but rough, signal).

Decision data not available here. CourtListener, the main free source of court opinions, requires an account API key for automated access, so this site does not collect lower-court opinions. You can search CourtListener for this court's opinions yourself (external site).

Who appointed the current judges

Appointed by a Democratic president: 1Appointed by a Republican president: 16

Judges

JudgeStatusAppointed byCommissionedSenate confirmation
Reed Charles O'Connor Chief JudgeActiveR George W. BushNov 21, 2007Nov 16, 2007 · voice vote
Sam A. LindsayActiveD William J. ClintonMar 17, 1998Mar 11, 1998 · voice vote
James E. KinkeadeActiveR George W. BushNov 15, 2002Nov 14, 2002 · voice vote
Karen Gren ScholerActiveR Donald J. TrumpMar 6, 2018Mar 5, 2018 · roll call 95–0
Matthew Joseph KacsmarykActiveR Donald J. TrumpJun 21, 2019Jun 19, 2019 · roll call 52–46
Mark Timothy PittmanActiveR Donald J. TrumpAug 5, 2019Jul 31, 2019 · roll call 54–36
Brantley David StarrActiveR Donald J. TrumpAug 6, 2019Jul 31, 2019 · roll call 51–39
James Wesley HendrixActiveR Donald J. TrumpAug 8, 2019Jul 30, 2019 · roll call 89–1
Ada Elene BrownActiveR Donald J. TrumpSep 13, 2019Sep 11, 2019 · roll call 80–13
Kasdin Miller MitchellActiveR Donald J. TrumpOct 2, 2026Sep 17, 2026 · roll call 49–45 (Voteview)
A[llen] Joe FishSenior status since Nov 12, 2007R Ronald ReaganFeb 24, 1983Feb 23, 1983 · voice vote
Robert B. MaloneySenior status since Aug 31, 2000R Ronald ReaganOct 17, 1985Oct 16, 1985 · voice vote
Sidney Allen FitzwaterSenior status since Sep 22, 2018R Ronald ReaganMar 19, 1986Mar 18, 1986 · roll call 52–42
Samuel Ray CummingsSenior status since Dec 31, 2014R Ronald ReaganDec 9, 1987Dec 8, 1987 · voice vote
Terry R. MeansSenior status since Jul 3, 2013R George H.W. BushNov 5, 1991Oct 31, 1991 · voice vote
David C. GodbeySenior status since Sep 18, 2025R George W. BushAug 2, 2002Aug 1, 2002 · voice vote
Jane J. BoyleSenior status since Oct 1, 2025R George W. BushJun 29, 2004Jun 17, 2004 · roll call 99–0

Source: Federal Judicial Center, Biographical Directory of Article III Federal Judges. “Commissioned” is the date the appointment took effect. Confirmation votes are as listed by the FJC (ayes–nays); recent roll calls link to Voteview where found.